ReThinking Campaign Finance Reform

by Datechguy | January 31st, 2013

Readability

ReThinking Campaign Finance Reform

I’ve long had the opin­ion that there is no sense in hav­ing com­pli­cated cam­paign finance laws.

The lim­its on cam­paign con­tributes and the rules on din­ners and where you can fund raise sim­ply cre­ate Byzan­tine schemes to defy or skit the law. It’s a full employ­ment scheme for con­sul­tants and lawyers who make a good liv­ing tak­ing their clients as close to the side­lines of the law as they can with­out going out-​of-​bounds.

I’ve always found this waste­ful, imprac­ti­cal non­sense, par­tic­u­larly in an inter­net age. My thought has always been: No lim­its, full dis­clo­sure and huge penal­ties for non-​disclosure. That increases the incen­tive for peo­ple to openly give what they want and full dis­clo­sure means when a can­di­date or sit­ting pol is being bought you know it.

This plan rests on two pillars:

The peo­ple. If the peo­ple have access to this infor­ma­tion via the net, they can dis­cover who is pay­ing what to who. This gives every voter has the abil­ity to make an informed deci­sion if they choose to.

The press: It would require lit­tle effort for the press to access such a pub­lic data­base, in fact one would assume a large city paper would assign at least a few peo­ple to mon­i­tor it. A smaller paper might do the same for their mem­ber of con­gress and sen­a­tors and the mem­bers of the state leg­is­la­tures in their dis­trict. It assures them of a nice three-​story sequence with com­men­tary to wit:

Report­ing of said con­tri­bu­tion: “Amal­ga­mated Wid­gets of Walla Walla today make a large con­tri­bu­tion to con­gress­man Igot Big­pock­ets (R-​Walla Walla) in the amount of $35,000. Con­gress­man big­pock­ets sits on the com­mit­tee that super­vises the export of pro­pri­etary wid­gets to Asia.“

Report­ing of com­ments or lack thereof: “Amal­ga­mated Wid­gets had no com­ment on their large con­tri­bu­tion to the cam­paign of con­gress­man Big­pock­ets yes­ter­day. When asked for com­ment con­gress­man Big­pock­ets spokes­woman I. Candi said: ‘The con­gress­man appre­ci­ates the sup­port of an employer of so many in his dis­trict and will fight to help keep those jobs in Walla Walla.’”

Analy­sis of the moves: “With a bill relax­ing wid­get export rules in com­mit­tee con­gress, Amal­ga­mated Wid­gets is tax­ing no chances. With the envi­ron­men­tal group AOTBS (Amer­i­can Opposed to Build­ing Stuff) lav­ish­ing dol­lars on com­mit­tee mem­bers to keep the bill stalled Amal­ga­mated decided it was time to go all in.“

and com­men­tary: from the left: “The appar­ent own­er­ship of con­gress­man Big­pock­ets by amal­ga­mated couldn’t be more clear if it was 1767 and he was a man named Kunta Kinte stand­ing on a block in Vir­gina.” and from the right: “The Irony of the activists of AOTBS derid­ing indus­try while chat­ter­ing away on cell phones and tap­ping on their tablets is only exceeded by their ultra rich sup­port­ers with large stakes in Xai Wid­gets Inter­na­tional who stands to lose most from this bill.”

Such a sys­tem in the­ory would work fine, the data would be out there, active and involved vot­ers will get the infor­ma­tion and act on it, while thanks to the press reports on it more pas­sive vot­ers will have at least an inkling of what is going on.

How­ever the more I see how far the left the press has gone where we’ve reached a point where sex scan­dals involv­ing US Sen­a­tors and under­age hook­ers are not news­wor­thy while videos can be altered to cre­ate out­rage to sup­port an issue and where “Look at the ass on her” doesn’t draw a com­ment from Fem­i­nist authors. I must con­clude there is lit­tle or no chance under the sys­tem I envi­sion of money going to lib­eral pols from lib­eral con­trib­u­tors from busi­ness or groups on the left to enter into the conversation.

Given that sit­u­a­tion, these lousy and incom­pre­hen­si­ble laws are the only restraint on the influ­ence or restraint to the out­right pur­chase of the pols of the left.

Until and unless we of the right gain a stronger voice in media and cul­ture we will have to set­tle for the law to pro­vide the stick that the press will not.

I’ve long had the opinion that there is no sense in having complicated campaign finance laws.

The limits on campaign contributes and the rules on dinners and where you can fund raise simply create Byzantine schemes to defy or skit the law. It’s a full employment scheme for consultants and lawyers who make a good living taking their clients as close to the sidelines of the law as they can without going out-of-bounds.

I’ve always found this wasteful, impractical nonsense, particularly in an internet age. My thought has always been: No limits, full disclosure and huge penalties for non-disclosure. That increases the incentive for people to openly give what they want and full disclosure means when a candidate or sitting pol is being bought you know it.

This plan rests on two pillars:

The people. If the people have access to this information via the net, they can discover who is paying what to who. This gives every voter has the ability to make an informed decision if they choose to.

The press: It would require little effort for the press to access such a public database, in fact one would assume a large city paper would assign at least a few people to monitor it. A smaller paper might do the same for their member of congress and senators and the members of the state legislatures in their district. It assures them of a nice three-story sequence with commentary to wit:

Reporting of said contribution: “Amalgamated Widgets of Walla Walla today make a large contribution to congressman Igot Bigpockets (R-Walla Walla) in the amount of $35,000. Congressman bigpockets sits on the committee that supervises the export of proprietary widgets to Asia.”

Reporting of comments or lack thereof: “Amalgamated Widgets had no comment on their large contribution to the campaign of congressman Bigpockets yesterday. When asked for comment congressman Bigpockets spokeswoman I. Candi said: ‘The congressman appreciates the support of an employer of so many in his district and will fight to help keep those jobs in Walla Walla.’”

Analysis of the moves: “With a bill relaxing widget export rules in committee congress, Amalgamated Widgets is taxing no chances. With the environmental group AOTBS (American Opposed to Building Stuff) lavishing dollars on committee members to keep the bill stalled Amalgamated decided it was time to go all in.”

and commentary: from the left: “The apparent ownership of congressman Bigpockets by amalgamated couldn’t be more clear if it was 1767 and he was a man named Kunta Kinte standing on a block in Virgina.” and from the right: “The Irony of the activists of AOTBS deriding industry while chattering away on cell phones and tapping on their tablets is only exceeded by their ultra rich supporters with large stakes in Xai Widgets International who stands to lose most from this bill.”

Such a system in theory would work fine, the data would be out there, active and involved voters will get the information and act on it, while thanks to the press reports on it more passive voters will have at least an inkling of what is going on.

However the more I see how far the left the press has gone where we’ve reached a point where sex scandals involving US Senators and underage hookers are not newsworthy while videos can be altered to create outrage to support an issue and where “Look at the ass on her” doesn’t draw a comment from Feminist authors. I must conclude there is little or no chance under the system I envision of money going to liberal pols from liberal contributors from business or groups on the left to enter into the conversation.

Given that situation, these lousy and incomprehensible laws are the only restraint on the influence or restraint to the outright purchase of the pols of the left.

Until and unless we of the right gain a stronger voice in media and culture we will have to settle for the law to provide the stick that the press will not.

Comments are closed.

DaTechGuy on DaRadio Saturday Noon EST. WBNW AM 1120 Concord WPLM 1390 Plymouth WESO 970 Southbridge, FTR Radio, the 405 Media

money matters 003

Get Cash for Your Pallets! 1-(800) 248-7543

aaron test

jeffrey’s

jeffrey’s

Buy Raspberry Ketone Here

American 023

Belanger Hardware 284 Water St · Fitchburg · (978) 342-2912

belanger 2

Try the Double Burger!

nashoba

Annie’s Book Stop of Worcester

Annies Book Stop of Worcester 001

Find Discounts at the Stores you Love

TOP STORES

pottery paintin place

pottery paintin place

The Navy Seals in their First Mission

The Navy Seals in their First Mission

Get yours for Kindle Here

Get yours for Kindle Here

Listen to your Granny

RWG

Bernard PC 774-322-6045

Bernard PC 774-322-6045

Support our favorite Charties

Read me at Examiner.com

Examiner badge2

Only 114 Million Hits to retirement!

Monthly Goal (Wage plus Writers) $1445

Olimometer 2.52

Most Innovative Blogger 2013

Most Innovative Blogger 2013

Tags

Help a Brother Knight of Mine who needs a hand