How Weak is ANTIFA’s ideology if They Can’t Out Argue Nazis?

Readability

How Weak is ANTIFA's ideology if They Can't Out Argue Nazis?

Today are being greeted by a full quote press by the MSM not only sug­gest­ing that cri­tiquing ANTIFA thugs for com­mit­ting vio­lence is “sup­port” for mod­ern Nazis but obscenely we’re actu­ally see­ing peo­ple who should know bet­ter equat­ing World War 2 vets like my father who served in the Pacific, my Father-​in-​law who served in Europe, my uncle Joe who was badly wounded in Italy My uncle John who was wounded in France and my cousin died fight­ing the 3rd Reich with Antifa thugs.

We are also get­ting the com­pletely expected sight of folks like Mitt Rom­ney play­ing the same game iron­i­cally for­get­ting that the same left­ists were call­ing him a Nazi just a few years ago (and thus jus­ti­fied if they choose to beat him or George W. Bush or any other mem­ber of the GOP who they have called Nazis).

Now I have no prob­lem in com­ing down on Neo Nazis. Not only are Neo Nazis bad but they, after see­ing the costs and the tyranny and the destruc­tion that Nazism caused, still choose to embrace it. That makes them dou­bly wrong (and/​or incred­i­bly stu­pid) but this raises a rather obvi­ous question.

All Amer­i­cans, even ones who espouse fool­ish and destruc­tive ide­olo­gies have the rights guar­an­teed by the first amend­ment. There­fore as long as peo­ple get the required per­mits for a pub­lic assem­bly, any Amer­i­cans, even neo nazis, have an absolute right to make their case in the court of pub­lic opinion.

And that brings us to an obvi­ous ques­tion: How hard is it to out argue a Nazi?

The National Social­ist régime was mur­der­ous, repres­sive and led to one of the most costly wars in the his­tory of the 20th cen­tury. I sub­mit and sug­gest that given those facts and that Amer­ica fought a 42 month war to destroy it , mak­ing the case against National Social­ism should be one of the eas­i­est tasks there is.

Yet the so called “ANTIFA” folks are not only unable to do so but can only counter the argu­ments of Neo Nazi’s by violence.

This would seem rather odd, how is it pos­si­ble that ANTIFA can’t make a case per­sua­sive enough to counter a bunch of National Socialists?

Again the answer is pretty sim­ple. Their ide­ol­ogy is not any better.

Rather than National Social­ism, what they argue for is anti-​capitalist Com­mu­nist Social­ism. The same com­mu­nist social­ism that between the Soviet Union and China man­aged to slaugh­ter 100 mil­lion peo­ple in the 20th cen­tury. Not only has their ide­ol­ogy been tried even more times than Nazism but because it has been tried in mul­ti­ple coun­tries on mul­ti­ple con­ti­nents it had a chance to cause even more slaugh­ter, suf­fer­ing and star­va­tion that the National Social­ists man­aged to achieve.

In other words their ide­ol­ogy is just as failed, just as mur­der­ous bad and con­se­quently just as easy to counter.

And that’s why ANTIFA is all about vio­lence, like the Nazi they can’t make a cred­i­ble argu­ment for their beliefs, but unlike these Nazi’s who appar­ently haven’t quite fig­ured out that they have an argu­ment that won’t sell, they know­ing peo­ple won’t buy what they’re sell­ing have decided to bypass the whole pub­lic assem­bly first amend­ment bit and decided to silence any who oppose them by vio­lence because they know their argu­ment is so pathetic they can’t even out argue a bunch of Nazis.

Clos­ing thought: What does it say about the argu­ments of the pro­fes­sional left and the media left that they seem des­per­ate to white­wash ANTIFA vio­lence and make any cri­tique of them beyond the pale, could it be that they under­stand that their own argu­ment are weak and want to use ANTIFA as mus­cle to keep peo­ple afraid of coun­ter­ing them?


If you want a source of report­ing other than the MSM please con­sider hit­ting DaTip­Jar below.




Please con­sider sub­scrib­ing, Not only does that get you my weekly pod­cast emailed to you before it appears either on the site or at the 405media which gra­ciously car­ries it on a weekly basis but if you sub­scribe at any level I will send you an auto­graphed copy of my new book from Imholt Press: Hail Mary the Per­fect Protes­tant (and Catholic) Prayer


Choose a Sub­scrip­tion level



Today are being greeted by a full quote press by the MSM not only suggesting that critiquing ANTIFA thugs for committing violence is “support” for modern Nazis but obscenely we’re actually seeing people who should know better equating World War 2 vets like my father who served in the Pacific, my Father-in-law who served in Europe, my uncle Joe who was badly wounded in Italy My uncle John who was wounded in France and my cousin died fighting the 3rd Reich with Antifa thugs.

We are also getting the completely expected sight of folks like Mitt Romney playing the same game ironically forgetting that the same leftists were calling him a Nazi just a few years ago (and thus justified if they choose to beat him or George W. Bush or any other member of the GOP who they have called Nazis).

Now I have no problem in coming down on Neo Nazis. Not only are Neo Nazis bad but they, after seeing the costs and the tyranny and the destruction that Nazism caused, still choose to embrace it. That makes them doubly wrong (and/or incredibly stupid) but this raises a rather obvious question.

All Americans, even ones who espouse foolish and destructive ideologies have the rights guaranteed by the first amendment. Therefore as long as people get the required permits for a public assembly, any Americans, even neo nazis, have an absolute right to make their case in the court of public opinion.

And that brings us to an obvious question: How hard is it to out argue a Nazi?

The National Socialist regime was murderous, repressive and led to one of the most costly wars in the history of the 20th century. I submit and suggest that given those facts and that America fought a 42 month war to destroy it , making the case against National Socialism should be one of the easiest tasks there is.

Yet the so called “ANTIFA” folks are not only unable to do so but can only counter the arguments of Neo Nazi’s by violence.

This would seem rather odd, how is it possible that ANTIFA can’t make a case persuasive enough to counter a bunch of National Socialists?

Again the answer is pretty simple. Their ideology is not any better.

Rather than National Socialism, what they argue for is anti-capitalist Communist Socialism. The same communist socialism that between the Soviet Union and China managed to slaughter 100 million people in the 20th century. Not only has their ideology been tried even more times than Nazism but because it has been tried in multiple countries on multiple continents it had a chance to cause even more slaughter, suffering and starvation that the National Socialists managed to achieve.

In other words their ideology is just as failed, just as murderous bad and consequently just as easy to counter.

And that’s why ANTIFA is all about violence, like the Nazi they can’t make a credible argument for their beliefs, but unlike these Nazi’s who apparently haven’t quite figured out that they have an argument that won’t sell, they knowing people won’t buy what they’re selling have decided to bypass the whole public assembly first amendment bit and decided to silence any who oppose them by violence because they know their argument is so pathetic they can’t even out argue a bunch of Nazis.

Closing thought: What does it say about the arguments of the professional left and the media left that they seem desperate to whitewash ANTIFA violence and make any critique of them beyond the pale, could it be that they understand that their own argument are weak and want to use ANTIFA as muscle to keep people afraid of countering them?


If you want a source of reporting other than the MSM please consider hitting DaTipJar below.




Please consider subscribing, Not only does that get you my weekly podcast emailed to you before it appears either on the site or at the 405media which graciously carries it on a weekly basis but if you subscribe at any level I will send you an autographed copy of my new book from Imholt Press: Hail Mary the Perfect Protestant (and Catholic) Prayer


Choose a Subscription level