The Comfortable Left’s Emotional Victory in the Boston Bubble World

Readability

The Comfortable Left's Emotional Victory in the Boston Bubble World

Saru­man: Vic­tory at Helm’s deep does not belong to you, Théo­den Horse Mas­ter, you are a lesser son of greater sires.

The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King (extended ver­sion) 2003

Christie: What’s the qui­etest Island in the area
Vir­gil: I’d say Kemo
Gru­ber: Yep Kimo, Quiet like a library.
Christie: Well When we land on that quiet lit­tle Island what do you think hap­pens?
Ensign Parker: I dunno?
Christie: Bing­ham­tom run smack into a Japan­ese Scout, he engages him in com­bat. He saves our whole crew and we send him back to the Offi­cers club a hero!

McHale’s Navy, The Captain’s Mis­sion 1963

I’ve been think­ing about what what the results of events this week­end on the Boston Com­mon will be. There will be sig­nif­i­cant con­se­quences polit­i­cally both locally and nation­ally (although not in the way some might think) But there is one per­spec­tive that I want to address because it is inde­pen­dent of the var­i­ous polit­i­cal agen­das out there.

As I men­tioned in my post Sun­day. Saturday’s events drew a large amount peo­ple who while non-​activists have spent their life­time in the media/​academic bub­ble of lib­er­al­ism. I sus­pect for such peo­ple, attend­ing this event was some­thing of crit­i­cal impor­tance to their self image.

For their entire lives they have heard the sto­ries of those who had come before them. Their grand­fa­thers and great grand­fa­thers who had fought in World War two, risk­ing their lives to check the advance of a mur­der­ous fas­cism on the world. They saw their sto­ries lion­ized in his­tory and media for (oddly enough the story of those same folks stop­ping the advance of mur­der­ous Com­mu­nism in Korea thus secur­ing the abil­ity of South Kore­ans to live mod­ern lives didn’t make the lion­iza­tion cut). Their par­ents or grand­par­ents lived in the civil rights era where peo­ple actu­ally risked life and limb to secure basic civil rights for those oppressed by Jim Crow also cel­e­brated in media and academia.

Fur­ther­more in that same media bub­ble they have been told for over a decade that the Gay Mar­riage debate is not a mat­ter of debate (at least not since Obama’s 2012 elec­tion year epiphany) and the Trans­gen­der debates that fol­lowed were yet another chap­ter in the civil rights.

They have been assured of all of these things, and have looked at their com­fort­able lives with the lat­est phones, and gad­gets, enter­tain­ment streamed to their homes on demand, attend­ing uni­ver­si­ties where the going rate for their edu­ca­tion is larger than the per cap­i­tal income of most of the coun­tries of the world an what they spend on cable and Star­bucks annu­ally alone is more that the per capita income in dif­fer­ent 30 countries.

Yet what had they done or sac­ri­ficed or risked to get these things? What had they done to be wor­thy of those who came before them?

For such peo­ple the events on the Boston Com­mon were a godsend.

For the cost of a train ticket, park­ing and mak­ing a sign they could be seen and counted as stand­ing up to one of the great his­tor­i­cal evils at risk to them­selves. Instead of fight­ing com­puter gen­er­ated Nazis online, you would be putting your­self out there for the cause of right and jus­tice and be cel­e­brated for it by the media, by your fel­lows, and online for doing so.

Yeah I know things weren’t as iffy as they might have been led to believe

Sure the mayor of Boston made sure the police would be there in force keep­ing deadly weapons out of people’s hands and mit­i­gat­ing the actual risk to nearly zero

Sure the num­ber of peo­ple who in the crowd on your side out­num­bered those you were counter protest­ing by a fac­tor of any­where from 1001000.

Sure despite the assur­ances of the media and activists that you were oppos­ing Nazi and the Klan the pres­ence of Nazis and Klans­man on the Boston com­mon was more the­o­ret­i­cal that actual

Sure the nasty look­ing guys in black wear­ing mask were on your side and only a dan­ger to Police or peo­ple who dared walk though the Boston Com­mon wear­ing Trump ban­ners or Israeli Flags.

and I’m sure some who were there see­ing facts (which they in fair­ness had no con­trol over any­way) beyond their bub­ble world and laugh at their wor­ries. But a lot of oth­ers will go home, post self­ies on insta­gram and point out the news cov­er­age to fam­ily talk­ing about being there in Boston con­fronting the Nazis.

And in the weeks and months to come in that bub­ble world they inhabit they’ll, around a beer on the col­lege com­mon, or at their local Star­bucks or over a glass of wine at a party or cook­out talk about that fate­ful day on the com­mon to their fel­low bub­ble dwellers sound­ing some­thing like this:

Cap­tain Bing­ham­ton: Oh I tell you it was rough gen­tle­men rough I don’t care what actions you’ve seen unless you were at Kimo.

To them it will be sim­ple truth because no mat­ter what actu­ally hap­pened on the com­mon that day, they had gone to Boston to prove they they were just as will­ing to put them­selves on the line as those peo­ple who came before them and the feel­ing they made a dif­fer­ence was real and authentic.

That was the emo­tional vic­tory they had fought for and those who share and depend on that bub­ble world will cel­e­brate that vic­tory with them for as long as they can keep that bub­ble intact.



If you want a source of report­ing other than the MSM please con­sider hit­ting DaTip­Jar below.




Please con­sider sub­scrib­ing, Not only does that get you my weekly pod­cast emailed to you before it appears either on the site or at the 405media which gra­ciously car­ries it on a weekly basis but if you sub­scribe at any level I will send you an auto­graphed copy of my new book from Imholt Press: Hail Mary the Per­fect Protes­tant (and Catholic) Prayer


Choose a Sub­scrip­tion level



Saruman:  Victory at Helm’s deep does not belong to you, Théoden Horse Master, you are a lesser son of greater sires.

The Lord of the Rings:  Return of the King (extended version) 2003

Christie:  What’s the quietest Island in the area
Virgil:  I’d say Kemo
Gruber: Yep Kimo, Quiet like a library.
Christie: Well When we land on that quiet little Island what do you think happens?
Ensign Parker: I dunno?
Christie: Binghamtom run smack into a Japanese Scout, he engages him in combat. He saves our whole crew and we send him back to the Officers club a hero!

McHale’s Navy, The Captain’s Mission 1963

I’ve been thinking about what what the results of events this weekend on the Boston Common will be.  There will be significant consequences politically both locally and nationally (although not in the way some might think) But there is one perspective that I want to address because it is independent of the various political agendas out there.

As I mentioned in my post Sunday.  Saturday’s events drew a large amount people who while non-activists have spent their lifetime in the media/academic bubble of liberalism.  I suspect for such people, attending this event was something of critical importance to their self image.

For their entire lives they have heard the stories of those who had come before them.  Their grandfathers and great grandfathers who had fought in World War two,  risking their lives to check the advance of a murderous fascism on the world.  They saw their stories lionized in history and media for (oddly enough the story of those same folks stopping the advance of murderous Communism in Korea thus securing the ability of South Koreans to live modern lives didn’t make the lionization cut). Their parents or grandparents lived in the civil rights era where people actually risked life and limb to secure basic civil rights for those oppressed by Jim Crow also celebrated in media and academia.

Furthermore in that same media bubble they have been told for over a decade that the Gay Marriage debate is not a matter of debate (at least not since Obama’s 2012 election year epiphany) and the Transgender debates that followed were yet another chapter in the civil rights.

They have been assured of all of these things, and have looked at their comfortable lives with the latest phones, and gadgets, entertainment streamed to their homes on demand, attending universities where the going rate for their education is larger than the per capital income of most of the countries of the world an what they spend on cable and Starbucks annually alone is more that the per capita income in different 30 countries.

Yet what had they done or sacrificed or risked to get these things?  What had they done to be worthy of those who came before them?

For such people the events on the Boston Common were a godsend.

For the cost of a train ticket, parking and making a sign they could be seen and counted as standing up to one of the great historical evils at risk to themselves.  Instead of fighting computer generated Nazis online, you would be putting yourself out there for the cause of right and justice and be celebrated for it by the media, by your fellows, and online for doing so.

Yeah I know things weren’t as iffy as they might have been led to believe

Sure the mayor of Boston made sure the police would be there in force keeping deadly weapons out of people’s hands and mitigating the actual risk to nearly zero

Sure the number of people who in the crowd on your side outnumbered those you were counter protesting by a factor of anywhere from 100-1000.

Sure despite the assurances of the media and activists that you were opposing Nazi and the Klan the presence of Nazis and Klansman on the Boston common was more theoretical that actual

Sure the nasty looking guys in black wearing mask were on your side and only a danger to Police or people who dared walk though the Boston Common wearing Trump banners or Israeli Flags.

and I’m sure some who were there seeing facts (which they in fairness had no control over anyway) beyond their bubble world and laugh at their worries.  But a lot of others will go home,  post selfies on instagram and point out the news coverage to family talking about being there in Boston confronting the Nazis.

And in the weeks and months to come in that bubble world they inhabit they’ll, around a beer on the college common, or at their local Starbucks or over a glass of wine at a party or cookout talk about that fateful day on the common to their fellow bubble dwellers sounding something like this:

Captain Binghamton: Oh I tell you it was rough gentlemen rough I don’t care what actions you’ve seen unless you were at Kimo.

To them it will be simple truth because no matter what actually happened on the common that day, they had gone to Boston to prove they they were just as willing to put themselves on the line as those people who came before them and the feeling they made a difference was real and authentic.

That was the emotional victory they had fought for and those who share and depend on that bubble world will celebrate that victory with them for as long as they can keep that bubble intact.



If you want a source of reporting other than the MSM please consider hitting DaTipJar below.




Please consider subscribing, Not only does that get you my weekly podcast emailed to you before it appears either on the site or at the 405media which graciously carries it on a weekly basis but if you subscribe at any level I will send you an autographed copy of my new book from Imholt Press: Hail Mary the Perfect Protestant (and Catholic) Prayer


Choose a Subscription level