The Ahmadi Catch 22

1st Romana: You know, if Grendel does become king, he’ll never make you his queen.
Madame Lamia: Nor you, either. I will see to that.

1st Romana: Ah, but I don’t want him and you do, don’t you. Look, why don’t you let me go? All you have to do is release me and the Doctor, and I’ll leave Tara. Think about it. What have you got to lose?
Madame Lamia: Grendel.
1st Romana: Well, you haven’t exactly got him now, have you? All he’s doing is using you.
Madame Lamia: I know. But that is better than nothing.

Doctor Who  The Androids of Tara 1978

Yesterday I wrote about the contrast of a Radical Islamic group & a representative of the US Army fighting on one side of the War Against Christmas while a local Imam was on the other:

Did you ever think you’d see the day when an Islamic Sect is more friendly toward Christmas than a representative of the US Army?

When Jaded by Politics tweeted out the No Christmas Story from the Army & tweeted out the story of the local Imam.  This led to an exchange with an Ahmadiyya follower in England.

@DaTechGuyblog #Ahmadiyya is the true Islam regardless of what our opponents say about us. Wasn’t Jesus treated as a liar? @JadedByPolitics

— Bilal Mahmood (@bilalmahmooduk) December 26, 2013

When I said nice things about Ahmadiyya vs radical Islam Jaded tweeted this:

@DaTechGuyblog @bilalmahmooduk gosh don’t get them killed man….LOL! never say anything nice about anyone attached to a murderous cult!

— JadedByPolitics (@JadedByPolitics) December 26, 2013

Unfortunately it’s much too late for that

The minarets and verses were covered up, apparently to the police’s satisfaction, but a baying mob gathered at one worship place the next day and demanded that the minarets be torn down. The police did so. The group of protesters is now demanding that similar action be taken against two other worship places within a couple of days.

The cleric whose complaint led to the action told The Express Tribune that he had approached the police after he attended a Khatm-i-Nabuwwat Conference on September 7, marking the anniversary of the passage of anti-Ahmadi laws, where a speaker said that Ahmadis were not allowed to build minarets or use verses from the Quran at their places of worship.

Sections 298-B and 298-C of the Pakistan Penal Code outlaw Ahmadis from calling their place of worship a masjid, claiming to be Muslims or preaching their faith to others.

It gets worse:

Sajeel Ahmed, 18, of Khushab was accused of making derogatory remarks about the Holy Prophet (peace be upon him) in a first information report (FIR) registered under Section 295-C of the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC), which carries the death penalty. The complainant is his classmate Waqas Nadeem, who said that Sajeel had tried to convert other students and made remarks that hurt their religious sentiments.

Sajeel’s father Hakim Jameel was accused of describing his son as a Muslim in his school admission form, an offence under Section 298-C of the PPC with a penalty of up to three years in prison. The complainant in the case is Qari Saeed Ahmed, who submitted that “the Muslims of Khushab are worried about the increasing number and activities of Qadianis in the city”.

Much worse:

On May 28, last year, 94 members of the Ahmadi community were massacred in their mosques during the Friday congregation in the eastern city of Lahore. Since then, Saleemuddin said, there has been a marked increase in persecution, with 11 more people killed.

Last year, the Punjab government made it mandatory for students to reveal whether they were ‘Muslim or non-Muslim’ before being admitted to school or college, or even before registering for the board exams.

There has been some coverage of it in the US:

Assembled in this way during the Muslim holy month of Ramadan, discussing the teachings of the Prophet Mohammed and their sect’s founder Hadhrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, could amount to a death sentence in some parts of the world. But the Masjid Bait-ul Qadir is on Milwaukee’s north side, where members of the local Ahmadiyya Muslim community — one of the oldest in the country — are free to worship as they please.

“We are just like other Muslims in that we follow the teachings of the Prophet Mohammed, the way we worship and the five basic pillars of the faith,” said Rizwan Ahmad of New Berlin, one of the leaders of the local mosque.

“The only difference is we believe that the messiah who is awaited by most of the major religions — other Muslims, Christians and Jews — has come in the person of our founder.”

For many mainstream Muslims, who are predominantly Sunni or Shiite, the small Ahmadiyya sect is one of heretics. Ahmadi are persecuted, even killed, in places such as Pakistan, Egypt, Saudi Arabia and Indonesia. And while there has been isolated violence in the United States — an Ahmadi man was murdered and a mosque torched in Detroit in the 1980s — difficulties locally have been described mostly as minor tensions, a heated debate among college students, or a personal slight at a gathering.

The Irony however is that some who would defend their rights point out their persecution they will get attacked:

The Ahmadis suffer persecution, oppression and slaughter at the hands of Muslims in so many Muslim countries because they attempted to reform/reinterpret jihad and Islam (claiming it to be “peaceful”). That’s bad enough. But the Ahmadis attack me for my defense of their rights. Oh yes, read this from Harris Zafar, National Spokesperson for the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community USA, in the Huffington Post: Confronting Pamela Geller (Updated With Response). My response is below Zafar’s suicidal screed. And it took an army ot tweeters to get the Puff Ho to run it.

It’s a catch 22 for the Ahmadis.  Because they are peaceful in an age where headlines involving Islam worldwide uniformly concern violence (Iraq, Nigeria etc etc etc) the US Muslim community and groups like CAIR highlight them whenever possible.  They long to be accepted by their Islamic brothers so they go along with this.

And because the crave that acceptance when people like Geller & Spencer point out this persecution and the excesses of radical Islam that they themselves suffer, folks like Harris Zafar side with their own oppressors.

That’s the Irony.  They are being used by the same groups that would be joining in their persecution in any majority Muslim nation.

Now if you ask me about Christian Theology I can give you an informed and educated opinion I can’t claim the same about Islam although I think the world would be a better place if the Ahmadi sect was the majority of Islam but until that day comes I do have a simple challenge to Mr. Zafar as a member of the Ahmadi community and to the people like CAIR who he backs.

I’ll believe that you truly accept you, the Ahmadi,  as a part of Islam when I see them fight to change this fact of life that Ahmadi’s must deal with.

Why do Ahmadis not perform Hajj?

Another objection that is raised is that why Ahmadis do not go for Hajj? Instead they go to their holy places in Qadian and Rabwah? Hajj is a pillar of Islam which they disrespect and they show more love for their own places rather than where the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, was born, therefore they are not Muslims through their actions!

Again a nonsense objection, how can Ahmadi Muslims go for Hajj when it is the Muslims themselves who are preventing them? Every Muslim must perform Hajj once in their lifetime, unless either the way is prevented, ill health or they cannot afford it. Ahmadi Muslims are prevented to go to Mecca for Hajj by the Saudi Government!  Furthermore, in Pakistan, you have to sign a form if you want to perform Hajj and Umra and on that form you are required to declare Hadhrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, may peace be upon him, as a false prophet!  No Ahmadi Muslim can sign such a form. Hajj is a rite in Islam which you do purely for Allah’s sake to attain the Nearness and Blessings of Allah. All worldly things should be left behind, even your clothes, as you are required to put on two white unsewn clothes – Ihram and so leave all worldly things behind, all fashion cloths etc. and instead everyone is the same, all Muslims striving for the same objectives. If that is the case, then why are they bringing politics into it!  Who are they to say who can do Hajj or not!  No doubt they will say that Hajj is only for Muslims, but if we declare the Kalima – la illaha illallaho Muhammad ur Rasoolullah, then who can tell us we are non-Muslims? Only Allah will judge if we are Muslims or not. It is not for the Saudi Government or the Pakistan Government to decide if we are Muslims or not. That being the case, then they have no right to prevent us. And then after preventing us from going to Hajj, then have the nerve to say we are not Muslims because we don’t go for Hajj!  May Allah have mercy on them.

Till they and other American Muslims fight for the right of Ahmadis to perform the hajj, I and people like me must conclude that CAIR and these other group’s only use for the Ahmadi is for the good PR they generate.